John Auger

Captain John Auger (Auger/Augier), from the 1948 Leaf Pirates trading card setJohn Auger (c. 1678

Rogers pardoned Auger ("a steady and respectable old pirate"), entrusted him with a sloop named Mary - owned by a David Soward and outfitted for trading - and allowed him to leave on the sloop Mary with two other ships on a resupply voyage. Soon after, Auger and his crew met with the other vessels at sea, including fellow pardoned pirate Phineas Bunce. Abandoning their trading mission, they reverted to piracy and plundered the two ships. Auger and Bunce debated whether to kill cargo master James Kerr, pilot Richard Turnley, and other officers Rogers had placed on board, but instead voted to maroon them.

Benjamin Hornigold had also accepted Rogers' pardon and had turned to hunting his former pirating comrades. He had been lying in wait for pirate Charles Vane; he captured Vane's accomplice Nicholas Woodall but missed Vane and returned to Nassau, where Rogers sent him after Auger and others in the area. Hornigold captured Auger and his crew later in 1718 after Auger's sloop was attacked by Spanish guarda costa privateer vessels led by Turn Joe, returning them to New Providence in the Bahamas. Rogers had no commission from England to hold an Admiralty Court to try captured pirates.

Auger testified that Phineas Bunce (who died of his injuries before he could be tried) was the mutiny's mastermind and that Auger himself had been "in Liquor" at the time, but could produce no evidence. The Court pardoned one man found to have been forced into piracy and ordered that all of the other pirates should "be hanged by the neck till you shall be dead, dead, dead". Captain Charles Johnson describes Auger's trip to the gallows:

... knowing himself guilty of the Indictment, he all along appeared very penitent, and neither wash'd, shav'd, or shifted his old Cloaths, when carried to be executed; and when he had a small Glass of Wine given him on the Rampart, drank it with Wishes for the good Success of the Bahama Islands and the Governor.

Auger and his crew had been captured, tried, convicted, and hanged within a year of returning to piracy.