Grigory Zinoviev

Grigory Yevseyevich Zinoviev (born Ovsei-Gershen Aronovich Radomyshelsky; – 25 August 1936) was a Russian revolutionary and Soviet politician. A prominent Old Bolshevik, Zinoviev was a close associate of Vladimir Lenin prior to 1917 and a leading figure in the early Soviet government. He served as chairman [predsedatel] of the Communist International (Comintern) from 1919 to 1926.

Zinoviev joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party in 1901 and sided with Vladimir Lenin's Bolsheviks in the party's 1903 split, forging a close political relationship with him. After participating in the failed Revolution of 1905, he served as Lenin's aide-de-camp in Europe.

An advocate of multi-party socialist government at the time of the October Revolution, Zinoviev joined with party moderate Lev Kamenev in opposing seizure of power by the Bolsheviks ahead of convening of the elected Constituent Assembly — in which the Bolsheviks would have been a minority. When Kamenev defended his views in a non-party radical newspaper, signing both his name and that of Zinoviev to the statement, Lenin was outraged and called for the expulsion of the pair as "strikebreakers," despite Zinoviev's condemnation of Kamenev's action.

Zinoviev subsequently lost the trust of Lenin, who began relying on Leon Trotsky as his chief associate. Zinoviev was nevertheless elected chairman of the Petrograd Soviet and the Comintern, and a full member of the Politburo in 1921.

During Lenin's final illness and after his death in 1924, Zinoviev allied with Kamenev and Joseph Stalin in a leadership "troika" against Trotsky. The arrangement fell apart, and in 1926 Zinoviev and Kamenev joined with Trotsky in the United Opposition against Stalin. Zinoviev was removed from the Politburo and Comintern in 1926 and was expelled from the party in 1927. He, like Kamenev, submitted to Stalin and rejoined the party the next year, after which he held mid-level positions. He and Kamenev were again expelled from the party in 1932, due to the Ryutin affair, and rejoined in 1933.

In 1934, Zinoviev was accused of complicity in the assassination of Sergei Kirov and was sentenced to ten years in prison. While imprisoned, Zinoviev was further accused of treason and other offenses during the Great Purge, and was executed after a show trial in August 1936.

Biography

Early years

Grigory Zinoviev was born Ovsei-Gershon Aronovich Radomyshelsky (ru: Овсей-Гершон Аронович Радомышельский, simplified to Радомысльский) in Yelizavetgrad, Russian Empire (now Kropyvnytskyi, Ukraine). He was the eldest son of Jewish dairy farmers Aron and Reizy Radomyshelsky, one of nine siblings. His mother's maiden name was Rozaliya Markovna Apfelbaum, a surname which is sometimes incorrectly cited as Zinoviev's original surname. He later asserted that he had finished five years of formal education in Russian schools, completing the high school curriculum.

Zinoviev was admitted to Switzerland's largest college, the University of Bern, in the fall of 1902, joining the mass of German and Russian students who accounted for about half the university's approximately 1,000 member student body. After completing the entrance examination, Zinoviev began studying for a degree in chemistry — a somewhat perplexing and never explained choice. He met V.I. Ulyanov (Lenin) for the first time in November 1902 when the latter was in Bern to deliver a lecture, helping to cement his affiliation to the Iskrists. Speaking on campus in Bern, Lunacharsky was less than impressed with the student he met, eight years his junior. Lunacharsky recalled in 1923:

"Radomyslsky...did not immediately strike me as very promising. He was rather a fat young man, pale and sickly, who suffered from shortness of breath and was, I thought, too phlegmatic in temperament. [His companion] Kazakov never allowed him to get a word in edgeways. However, after we had been in permanent touch with them for some time we became convinced that Radomyslsky was an efficient lad..."

Professional revolutionary

Zinoviev's first mission on behalf of the Bolsheviks came in the fall of 1903, when he was dispatched to Russia to attempt to build a party organization there. Using his hometown of Yelizavetgrad as a base of operations, Zinoviev traveled throughout the region on party assignment, including a mission to Kremenchuk, located about 65 miles to the north.

The Russian Revolution of 1905 having erupted in January, accompanied by a relaxation of state censorship of the press and the better opportunity for political organizing. In October, Zinoviev returned to Russia, this time to the capital city of St. Petersburg, where he joined the staff of the first legal Bolshevik newspaper, Novaya Zhizn''' [New Life]. He continued to work in St. Petersburg throughout 1907, taking time to attend the 5th (London) party congress in the spring of that year as one of the delegates of the Petersburg Committee. This would be the last joint congress including both the Menshevik and Bolshevik factions. Zinoviev was elected to two of the congresses' commissions and spoke to the gathering several times.

Zinoviev was elected a candidate member of the RSDLP Central Committee by that 1907 congress, collecting 143 votes. More importantly, he was named to the parallel factional leadership, the so-called "Bolshevik Center". Lenin left for Geneva to resume publication of the (illegal) party press there, with Zinoviev still in St. Petersburg, exchanging letters and coordinating newspaper distribution.

In addition to the Zinoviev nom de la guerra itself, at various times during his life in the revolutionary underground Zinoviev also used the pseudonyms "Zarin," "Zuev," and "Skopin."

First arrest and exile

On March 29, 1908, following a meeting of the editorial board of the Bolshevik paper Vperëd [Forward], the Okhrana picked up Zinoviev off the street and jailed him at a district police station. Despite being targeted, there was no evidence found on Zinoviev's person, nor was any evidence turned up in a subsequent raid on his home.

Zinoviev's Okhrana mugshot from the time of his arrest, March 1908. His wife began a campaign for his release, with the father of Bolshevik Elena Stasova, a prosperous and prominent lawyer, among those who seem to have played a particularly important in obtaining Zinoviev's release after about two months in custody. In addition to the lack of evidence, the series of appeals to provincial authorities emphasized Lilina's pregnancy and Zinoviev's poor health in addition to the general lack of concrete evidence in the case. According to terms of his release he was given three days to leave St. Petersburg before his stint of administrative exile back to Yelizavetgrad.

With his underground position deemed compromised, Zinoviev was called to Geneva by Lenin in August 1908, where his wife gave birth to their first child, a son.

In Paris Zinoviev adopted a new pseudonym, "Jean Shatsky", adding this to the names he had used for underground activity in Russia — Gregorev, Grigory, and Zinoviev. He worked as an editor of the Bolshevik factional organ, Proletarii, and was remembered by a typographer as having played the leading role in its production, allowing Lenin time for independent reading and writing. It was during this period that the pseudonym "Zinoviev" became his main signature and identity — the name being wordplay on his wife's pseudonym, "Zina".

He sided with Lenin in 1908 when the Bolshevik faction bitterly split into camps composed of Lenin's supporters and those supporting Alexander Bogdanov and he remained reliably committed to Lenin's various factional maneuvers. In the estimation of historian E.H. Carr, Zinoviev "seems to have been the only Bolshevik to stand at Lenin's side in Paris in January 1910 in opposition to the policy of compromise with the Mensheviks and to the maintenance of the united party Central Committee, and no doubt earned the leader's gratitude on that account." Zinoviev would remain Lenin's constant aide-de-camp and confidante until the Revolution of 1917.

After attending the 1910 Copenhagen Congress of the Second International together with top leaders of the Bolshevik faction Lenin, Kamenev, Lunacharsky, and Alexandra Kollontai, Zinoviev and his family relocated to the town of Longjumeau, located just south of Paris. This location was chosen for a party training school for Russian workers, presumably outside scrutiny of Parisian political intelligence officers and tsarist spies. An array of party intellectuals, including Lenin, Zinoviev, and Inessa Armand, served as lecturers, with Zinoviev teaching the history of the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party. Zinoviev was elected to the seven member Central Committee of the Bolshevik Party, and a new official organ, Rabochaya Gazeta (The Workers' Newspaper) was launched.

Galicia and Switzerland

Lenin found working in Paris to be difficult, with pervasive police surveillance and a cumbersome national library, so in the summer of 1912 he and his wife Krupskaya, together with Zinoviev and his wife Lilina, traveled to Kraków, Galicia (part of Austria–Hungary), where they rented a house together. The Zinoviev and Lenin families spent the next two summers together in Poronin, a small mountain town, before returning to Kraków each year in the fall. Neither left memoirs of their own, although Lenin's wife Nadya Krupskaya did publish a series of sketches, first gathered in book form as Vospominaniya o Lenine (Memoirs of Lenin) in 1926 — a work which was gradually expanded and politically "doctored" in subsequent editions of 1930, 1932, and 1934. After being mothballed for two decades, the book reissued in expanded form in 1957, published in English translation in 1960 as Reminiscences of Lenin. Little personal juice detailing the Lenin–Zinoviev exile relationship remained in this work, characterized by her biographer as a "partisan book," albeit one in which "nobody emerges as an 'enemy of the people' in the Stalinist sense."

Between the 1930 American (L) and 1931 British edition (R), Zinoviev's name was erased from the pamphlet Socialism and War , co-written with Lenin. During this period Zinoviev worked as a journalist and speechwriter for the Bolshevik organization, contributing a series of articles to the party press and writing for the party's representatives in the State Duma. It would be replaced by a new Bolshevik official organ, Sotsial–Demokrat, printed in Geneva and launched that same November.

The outbreak of World War I in August 1914 dramatically changed the situation for the Russian emigrant community in Galicia. As citizens of an enemy nation, Austro-Hungarian authorities cracked down on resident Russians as a security risk, with Lenin arrested on suspicion of espionage. Zinoviev and his wife were living apart from Lenin and Krupskaya in the town of Zakopane at this time, where the local authorities were less obsessed with the threat represented by anti-tsarist revolutionaries, allowing him to avoid a similar fate as that suffered by his friend and mentor. According to Zinoviev, Lenin wrote the entire first chapter of the four chapter work and parts of chapters 3 and 4. The Zimmerwald Left continued as a loose organizational entity after conclusion of the conference, with Lenin, Zinoviev, and Polish radical Karl Radek serving as a three-person directing body in Bern, publishing its own material and pushing for convocation of a new conference. By the end of the year only 10 of these remained outside of the Okhrana's clutches. Moreover, the party's secret press in the city was discovered and seized in December, essentially shutting down communications.

The sudden collapse of the tsarist regime in February (March new style) 1917 would seem to have been nothing short of miraculous.

The sealed train

Zinoviev was in Bern when he first saw printed confirmation that ongoing rumors of civil disturbances had proven true and had, in fact, culminated with the collapse of the 300-year old Romanov dynasty. He recalled:

"My head spun in the spring sun. I hurried home with the paper, which was not yet dry. There I found already a telegram from Vladimir Ilyich, ordering me to come 'immediately' to Zurich."

A committee of the Duma had decided to take power the evening of February 27 (March 12 n.s.), 1917, but it took three more days for a provisional government of the Russian Republic to emerge. Dominated by mild constitutionalists who distrusted and feared the possibility of wild popular unrest, two socialists from the Petrograd Soviet were co-opted into the new central authority — vice-chair Alexander Kerensky and Nikolai Chkheidze, a top figure in the Menshevik party and president of the Soviet's Executive Committee.

Transit map showing the route traveled Lenin and Zinoviev back to Russia on the "sealed train" following the February Revolution.

Russian radicals of all stripes who had fled tsarist persecution to neutral Switzerland were anxious to make an expeditious return to their homeland with the emergence of a democratic republic, but found themselves trapped by the ongoing European war. Great Britain and France, allies with Russia in the ongoing bloodbath against Germany and Austria–Hungary, prohibited anti-war Russian radicals from passage through their lines, although they did provide pro-war radicals such as Georgii Plekhanov and Pëtr Kropotkin safe passage. Frustration grew among the anti-war Russian left. Lenin was dissatisfied with the pace of progress by this united Émigré Committee, however, and decided to pursue repatriation on his own. At the end of March he sent out a message to all adherents of the Bolshevik Party who wished to return home to make contact with him.

Lenin, Zinoviev, Swiss radical Fritz Platten, and German Willi Münzenberg formed a committee of four to negotiate exact details of transit. The so-called sealed train was to have the status of an extraterritorial entity, with the neutral Swiss citizen Platten to act as the point of contact between the Russian travelers and their German guards. Others making the trip were Inessa Armand, reckoned by some historians to have been Lenin's former lover, and the gregarious Olga Ravich (party name: Sara Savvich), who had briefly been married to Zinoviev. The party held a spirited luncheon at the hotel, with Lenin delivering a fire-breathing revolutionary speech to those assembled. Following lunch, the 30 adults and 2 children boarded the train for departure, only to have the light meals they had packed removed by Swiss authorities in accord with a wartime regulation prohibiting the export of foodstuffs.

Sweden was persuaded to allow transit of the Russians only after the train had departed from Switzerland. Radek, burdened by his Austrian citizenship, was left in Stockholm to engage in party work there. The party proceeded into Finland, a semi-autonomous part of the Russian empire on its way to full independence after the fall of the Romanovs, where Lenin obtained issues of Pravda that informed him of the situation ahead, and news of the train's schedule was telegraphed ahead and a welcome party arranged. On April 16 (n.s.), the train carrying Lenin and his trusted right-hand man, Zinoviev, pulled into the station in Petrograd, with the party leader immediately issuing a call for a broader social revolution. The next phase of the Russian Revolution had begun.

The "July Days"

The fatal error of the rapid succession of Provisional Governments of Russia was remaining engaged in the European military bloodbath amidst total economic and social collapse. Head of the first government, the Constitutional Democrat Pavel Miliukov was heartened by American entry into the war in April and considered the popular slogan of "peace without annexations" to be a "German formula." A declaration of April 10 (n.s.) continued to advance the line that "the defense of our own inheritance by every means, and the liberation of our country from the invading enemy, constitute the foremost and most urgent task of our fighters, defending the nation's liberty." As the bodies of fallen soldiers continued to stack, tension between the self-appointed Provisional Government and the parallel system of elected councils (Soviets) continued to mount.

Protesters come under attack during the "July Days" melee, Petrograd, July 4 (17), 1917.

The afternoon of July 3, 1917, a group of largely spontaneous demonstrations broke out around Petrograd — soldiers opposing transfer to the front and workers protesting against unmet wage promises and food speculation. While more radical elements of the Bolshevik Party, such as its Military Organization, actively supported the street revolt against the government, the party's central leadership headed by Lenin and Zinoviev, sought to quell the disturbances, anxious to wait for a more opportune moment after the government's military offensive had failed convincingly, in a manner that absolved the Bolsheviks from any possible blame. Lenin was briefly away from the city on a short vacation, however, leaving Zinoviev to play an oversized role in attempting to stabilize and steer the "July Days" revolt. When an unruly throng congregated outside the Tauride Palace calling for Irakli Tsereteli, a Menshevik and top leader in the Provisional Government, it was Zinoviev who stepped forward to deliver a lengthy impromptu speech to the tens of thousands assmbled, ending with a successful call for the mob to peacefully disperse. The propaganda campaign against the Bolsheviks, with troops loyal to the government sacking the party's offices and printing ship and public sentiment turning decisively against the radicals. Arrest warrants were issued on July 6 with Lenin, Zinoviev, and other top leaders ordered to surrender. Lenin was made up to look like a Finnish peasant, while Zinoviev was outfitted in a "wide, light-colored coat with a multi-colored pattern" to look like a prosperous Baltic trader. Instead the pair spent several summer weeks camping out a hastily constructed leaf hut that Lenin's friend had built for them.

Zinoviev and Kamenev felt that the new wave of popular support for the Bolsheviks following the defeat of the attempted coup by Kornilov was unreliable. Moreover, they argued, successful alliances had been formed during the Kornilov insurrection with other radical parties; the Constituent Assembly, an institution bearing authority with the public at large, should therefore be the focus of Bolshevik efforts instead of an attempt at armed seizure of power. On October 17 (30), one day after the key meeting of the central committee that had divided over the matter, Gorky reported that two top Bolsheviks had opposed armed action.

Lenin nevertheless continued to believe that Zinoviev was intent upon sabotaging the central committee's decision and called for action against both as "strikebreakers," demanding their expulsion from the party, in letters to the party membership and to the central committee. Zinoviev's contribution was modest, including articles written for the Bolshevik official organ, Rabochii Put, which replaced Pravda after its ban in July, attending central committee meetings, and speaking with Lenin at the October 25 (Nov. 7) meeting of the Petrograd Soviet.

Ten days after the Bolshevik seizure of power, Zinoviev and Kamenev — together with Alexei Rykov, Vladimir Milyutin, and Victor Nogin — resigned their places on the central committee over the decision to exclude Left SRs (essentially an independent party from the regular Party of Socialist Revolutionaries) from the government.

In the immediate aftermath of the October Revolution, a great debate erupted in Bolshevik party councils over the parameters of the government that would follow. Lenin and Trotsky represented a hardline faction, rejecting negotiation with Menshevik and Right SR leaders to form a multi-party socialist government, instead hoping to instigate "immediate decisive socialist revolutions in the more advanced countries of Europe by means of a big revolutionary bang in Russia. Zinoviev aligned himself with Bolshevik moderates, headed by Lev Kamenev and including such party worthies as Alexei Rykov, Anatoly Lunacharsky, and David Riazanov, in efforts to negotiate with the powerful Menshevik- and SR-dominated All-Russian Executive Committee of the Union of Railway Workers (Vikzhel) and other unions to establish a multi-party government. Lozovsky charged the hardliners, operating through the Military Revolutionary Committee, with incitement of mob violence, restricting democracy through suppression of the opposition press, conducting persecution through arbitrary searches and arrests, and for deceiving the will of the masses by usurping civil governance in favor of rule by one party whose delays in governmental restructuring resulted only in a continuation of mob violence.

In the immediate aftermath of this heated December 17 meeting, Lenin sent a personal ultimatum to four Bolshevik Central Committee members associated with the moderates — Kamenev, Zinoviev, Riazanov, and Yuri Larin — threatening them with expulsion from the party unless they immediately submitted a written declaration promising to unflinchingly uphold the decisions of the Central Committee and to either promote its line or to withdraw from all public activity pending the final decision of the next party congress. Zinoviev as the only one of the four to take this threatening reprimand in silence, with Kamenev and his peers jointly pronouncing Lenin's demand an unprecedented demand to stifle a party member's freedom of conscience.

Kamenev was shortly replaced as head of the Central Executive Committee of Soviets by Bolshevik hardliner Yakov Sverdlov, whose rigid adherence to the Bolshevik line contributed to the atrophy of that committee as the chief decision-making institution, to be supplanted by the Council of People's Commissars (Sovnarkom), a formerly inferior body. Zinoviev, on the other hand, by breaking with Kamenev and the moderates and bending the knee to the hardline Central Committee of the party, found himself immediately back in the good graces of Lenin and the party majority.

Though lasting political damage remained, these transgressions were passed over unremarked, as it was a situation calling for all hands on deck for the Bolsheviks during the revolutionary period and the bitter civil war that followed. As Carr phrased it:

"These incidents were forgiven and, in large measure, forgotten by the party. But they left the impression of a basic timidity of character beneath a blustering exterior. Zinoviev shrank from the responsibility of decisive action, but shrank equally from the consequences of persisting in his opposition."

He became a non-voting member of the ruling Politburo when it was created after the VIII Congress on 25 March 1919. He also became the Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Comintern when it was created in March 1919. It was in this capacity he presided over the Congress of the Peoples of the East in Baku in September 1920 and gave his famous four-hour speech in German at the Halle congress of the Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany in October 1920.

Zinoviev was responsible for Petrograd's defence during two periods of intense clashes with White forces in 1919. Trotsky, who was in overall charge of the Red Army during the Russian Civil War, thought little of Zinoviev's leadership, which aggravated their strained relationship.

Comintern leader

Grigory Zinoviev is best remembered as the first president [predsedatel] of the Communist International (Comintern), holding that position since the organization's formation in 1919 until being removed some time shortly after the enlarged plenum of the Executive Committee of the Communist International (ECCI) held in February–March 1926.

Zinoviev was a logical choice to head the Comintern, having been active as he was in the international Zimmerwald movement during the war. further cementing his position as one of the top leaders of the Russian Communist Party.

The Founding Congress of the Comintern was a small and informal affair, held during the first week of March 1919. There were 52 people who participated, but only 12 were officially delegated representatives of radical political organizations, with perhaps 8 of these being representatives of the Russian Communist Party.

Joining Lenin and Zinoviev on this delegation to the founding convention were top leaders Leon Trotsky, Nikolai Bukharin, Georgy Chicherin, Vatslav Vorovsky, N. Osinsky, and perhaps Joseph Stalin, listed as a delegate but leaving no evidence of having actually participated. The blockade of Soviet Russia made attendance extremely difficult in the best case; others participated informally or without formal credentials, delegates by virtue of felicitously having been present in Moscow at the right moment.

Lenin spoke to open the gathering and Zinoviev conveyed the formal greetings of the Central Committee of Russian Communist Party, indicative of the relative positions of pair in the party hierarchy.

In the aftermath of the gathering Zinoviev squabbled with Angelica Balabanoff, who had served as secretary at the founding convention and who was among the small circle of individuals who helped to establish the Comintern's organization form, hosting initial meetings of ECCI in her Moscow living quarters until more permanent facilities could be maintained. As a result of these quarrels, Zinoviev established a parallel headquarters for the Comintern at the Smolny Institute in Petrograd, from which the organization issued its publications. The Smolny building was also used by Zinoviev as his headquarters as chair of the Petrograd Soviet, allowing him to retain and consolidate authority in both organizations.

Rise to the top (1921–1923)

In early 1921, when the Communist Party was split into several factions, and policy disagreements were threatening the unity of the Party, Zinoviev supported Lenin's faction. As a result, Zinoviev was made a full member of the Politburo after the 10th Party Congress on 16 March 1921, while members of other factions, such as Nikolai Krestinsky, were dropped from the Politburo and the Secretariat.

Zinoviev was one of the most influential figures in the Soviet leadership during Lenin's final illness in 1922–23 and immediately after his death in January 1924, joining with Lev Kamenev and Joseph Stalin to form a three-person triumvirate, sometimes referred to by the Russian word for a three horse sleigh, a troika. Zinoviev reportedly marshalled Stalin's candidacy for general secretary of the Communist Party at the 11th Party Congress in 1922, This view has been supported by several historians. According to Russian historian Vadim Rogovin, Stalin's election occurred after the 11th Party Congress, held at the end of March through early April 1922) in which Lenin, due to his poor health, participated only sporadically.

The leadership struggle accelerates

On March 9, 1923, Lenin suffered a second severe stroke, pushing the leadership of the Russian Communist Party into an even deeper flux. Zinoviev, Kamenev, and Stalin represented a majority on the Politburo, effectively making joint decisions as a triumvirate, with Trotsky isolated as a minority; the time was not ripe for an outright break, however, since the possibility of Lenin's full recovery remained possible while policy differences between the two groupings on industrial and agricultural policy not yet completely defined. The annual congress of the Russian Communist Party, scheduled for March 1923, was postponed until April 17 due to leadership turmoil associated with Lenin's sudden health setback.

During this interval, Zinoviev was the first among equals, the de facto leader of the party, head of the world communist organization, and the apparent heir to Lenin's chair.

Zinoviev and Trotsky immediately began to jockey for position to succeed Lenin after his latest health crisis, the two most logical candidates for the chief executive function. Zinoviev prepared a series of six lectures which he delivered early in 1923, reviewing the history of the Bolshevik party from its foundation down to February 1917. These were collected and released as a short book, The History of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks), eventually translated into English.

Trotsky possessed an outstanding mind and years of total commitment to the revolutionary cause, but was for years an outsider to the Bolshevik Party and owed his position of power to some great extent to Lenin's personal patronage.

Trotsky's report on industry to the 12th congress noted an escalation of the real price of industrial goods compared to the real price of agricultural commodities — the emergence of "price scissors" that would grow to become one of the main economic problems facing the Soviet government in the coming year. He did not declare this an insurmountable crisis or propose radical structural changes, however, and the 1923 party conclave effectively ratified the comparatively moderate, pro-peasant policies advocated by Zinoviev, Kamenev, and Stalin. Indeed, this was the period of "High NEP," and as British historian E.H. Carr observed, "no party held at this period and under Zinoviev's leadership could fail to pay its tribute to the primary importance of the peasant."

The "Literary Discussion" of 1924

The "Literary Discussion" was launched in October 1924 with the publication of the 1917 volume of Trotsky's collected works.

The fourth quarter 1924 was marked by the so-called "Literary Discussion" in which the various leading participants in the Lenin succession struggle began to take explicit aim at one another with pamphlets, books, and magazine articles. The first great salvo came October 14, with the publication of the third volume of Trotsky's Collected Works by the State Publishing House — a two-part volume focused on Trotsky's writings during the revolution of 1917.

Trotsky used the foreword of this book as the venue for a 60-page introductory essay, "Uroki Oktyabrya" (Lessons of October), an extensive summary of the events of 1917. In this essay, Trotsky noted in passing recent Comintern failures with revolutionary uprisings in Bulgaria and Germany, an implicit criticism of Zinoviev's leadership, before moving to revisit details of the October days, during which, according to Trotsky, "the right wing of the party sought to delay the development of events," believing, as did the Mensheviks, that the February revolution would lead inevitably to so-called "bourgeois parliamentarianism," that multiple years remained before the time would be ripe for proletarian revolution, and that the Central Committee's advocacy of armed insurrection thus marked a grievous error and a threat to the Bolshevik Party's existence.

Zinoviev and Kamenev's letter of October 11, "On the Current Sitaution," declaring armed insurrection to be a "risk not just to the fate of our party, but the fate of the Russian and international revolution as well," was emphasized. Clearly, these two would have preferred such a collywobble to have remained unmentioned. The essay was regarded as a full-frontal attack by Trotsky on the revolutionary credentials of the party leadership; the response by Zinoviev and the Politburo majority was immediate and vigorous.

On October 24, just ten days after Trotsky's volume had hit the street, the Central Committee issued a statement, over the signatures of Zinoviev and Kamenev, decrying Trotsky's new book introduction as "a conscious distortion of the history of the party" designed to promote "Comrade Trotsky's factional goals. The Central Committee sent additional instructions callling for the "distribution of appropriate works" dealing with the 1917 revolution — a clear signal for the release of a spate of new pamphlets to counter Trotsky's perspective.

Zinoviev's chief contribution to the anti-Trotsky campaign of 1924 was an article published on November 30 and frequently reprinted in pamphlet form, Bolshevism or Trotskyism? The massive article appeared simultaneously in Sunday editions of the official party daily, Pravda, as well as the official government daily, Izvestiya, and bluntly charged Trotsky with a conscious attempt to substitute an ill-defined "Trotskyism" directly for "Leninism." This followed a tag-team effort by Kamenev and Stalin on the same them that had similarly appeared in both publications the previous Wednesday, emphasizing for all readers the direction of the political winds then blowing.

Zinoviev would follow this effort up with a long book attempting to establish "Leninism" as a body of formal doctrine and to emphasize Trotsky's missteps and failures to adhere to it in 1925 with the publication of Leninism: Introduction to the Study of Leninism.

They and their supporters accused Trotsky of various mistakes during the Russian Civil War in order to damage his reputation, and alleged that he was plotting a military coup. This campaign prompted Trotsky to resign in protest as People's Commissar of Army and Fleet Affairs and Chairman of the Revolutionary Military Council in January 1925, stating that the constant political attacks made it impossible to carry out his duties as military leader. Zinoviev further demanded Trotsky's expulsion from the Communist Party, but Stalin refused to go along at that time and played the role of a mediator.

The break with Stalin

With Trotsky finally on the sidelines, the Zinoviev-Kamenev-Stalin triumvirate began to crumble. In the fall of 1924, Stalin, head of the Communist Party's Organization Bureau, in charge of job assignments, removed Zinoviev ally I. A. Zelensky as secretary of the Moscow party committee and transferred him to a position in Central Asia. In his place was installed N. A. Uglanov, a former party secretary in Petrograd who had frequently found himself at odds with Zinoviev. News of the gathering was reported to the Stalin–Bukharin majority faction, however, and on June 20 the Communist Party's disciplinary arm, the Central Control Commission, dominated by the Stalin–Bukharin faction, reprimanded the organizers and called for Lashevich's removal from his job and seat on the Central Committee. This document called for policy changes with resepect to wage rates, taxation, and agricultural focus, as well as making a protracted attack of "bureaucratic deformations of the party apparatus" that led to top-down decision-making and a denial of a right to criticize the actions of superiors.

"These severe bureaucratic defects in the party regime are what have made defendancts out of Comrades Lashevich and Belenky, whom the party has known for more than two decades aas devoted and disciplined members," this so-called "Declaration of the Thirteen" boldly asserted.

The denouement had been reached. On July 20, the governing presidium of the Central Control Commission, clearly acting in accordance with a private factional decision, decided to expand the focus of the Lashevich inquiry to include Zinoviev, owing to his and Belenky's close personal and political ties with the Comintern leader. In the bitter debate that followed, the majority Stalin group held sway, with the final resolution of the joint plenum declaring:

While holding all Party members participating in the factional struggle responsible for it, the Party cannot fail to hold Comrade Zinoviev...politically responsible for this divisive struggle; his like-minded associates are taking a most active part in factional work and are utilizing the apparatus of the [Comintern], which is subordinate to Comrade Zinoviev — especially given that Comrade Zinoviev has made not the slightest attempt to condemn these associates of his or to dissociate himself from them.... eeming it intolerable that the actual leadership of the opposition’s factional struggle is being carried out by a member of the Politburo of the CC, [it is resolved] to remove Comrade Zinoviev from the Politburo of the CC..."

Soon thereafter the post of the Comintern president was abolished, eliminating Zinoviev's final position of power.

Despite his demotion, Zinoviev refused to recant, remaining in opposition to Stalin and his majority faction into 1927. This decision resulting in his expulsion from the Central Committee in October 1927. When the United Opposition tried to organize independent demonstrations commemorating the 10th anniversary of the October Revolution in November 1927, the demonstrators were dispersed by force and Zinoviev and Trotsky were expelled from the Communist Party on November 12. Their leading supporters, from Kamenev down, were expelled in December 1927 by the 15th Party Congress, paving the way for mass expulsions of rank-and-file oppositionists as well as internal exile of opposition leaders in early 1928.

According to Zinoviev's testimony while in NKVD custody in December 1934, Zinoviev's political faction maintained an underground organization in Leningrad, complete with ward committees, in 1927 and 1928, with its participants having "melted away" by the latter date so that "after 1929 there was no organization at all." The Zinoviev opposition was thus effectively terminated.

Submission to Stalin (1928–1934)

While Trotsky remained firm in his opposition to Stalin after his expulsion from the Party and subsequent exile, Zinoviev and Kamenev capitulated almost immediately and called on their supporters to follow suit. They wrote open letters acknowledging their mistakes and were readmitted to the Communist Party after a six-month cooling off period. They never regained their Central Committee seats, but they were given mid-level positions within the Soviet bureaucracy. Bukharin, then at the beginning of his short and ill-fated struggle with Stalin, courted Kamenev and, indirectly, Zinoviev during the summer of 1928. This was soon reported to Stalin and used against Bukharin as proof of his factionalism.

After once more admitting their supposed mistakes, they were readmitted to the Party in December 1933. They were forced to make self-flagellating speeches at the 17th Party Congress in January 1934, with Stalin parading his erstwhile political opponents, now defeated and outwardly contrite.

The Kirov murder

Late in the afternoon of December 1, 1934, first secretary of the Leningrad Communist Party organization Sergei Kirov entered the Smolny building, the government's headquarters in the city. An address to a 6 pm meeting of party activists was on his agenda for the evening.

Sergei Kirov, assassinated chief of the Leningrad Communist Party organization.

As Kirov passed down the hallway to his office, an unemployed Communist named Leonid Nikolaev, who lay in wait with a briefcase in his hand and a revolver in his pocket, stepped from a restroom. Nikolaev allowed Kirov to pass, then circled behind him, following him from the main corridor to a small corridor leading to his office. The rich vein of archival documents now available seems to have relegated this material to the stacks as examples of misdirected Kremlinology, however.

The night of December 1/2, Nikolaev underwent his first round of interrogation, conducted by the central NKVD rather than local Leningrad officials. Nikolaev's wife and half-brother were also hauled in for questioning, with initial investigation focusing on building a timeline of activities for the Nikolaev brothers and focusing on a potential foreign connection between his wife, Milda Draule, her relatives in Latvia, and various German engineers. Surviving investigation protocols show a sharp change of focus on December 4, with Agranov beginning to press Nikolaev on his connections with "Zinovievites." As followers of Trotsky and Zinoviev had joined as a "United Opposition" in 1926–27 and stood side by side against the majority Stalin faction, this was regarded as a potentially critical connection since, as historian Matthew Lenoe has noted, "there was not a clear distinction between Zinovievite and Trotskyite ideas" during that interval. Indeed, Agranov directly informed Stalin by telegram the next day that "according to the testimony of Nikolaev...the Trotskyites Shatsky, Bardin, and Kotolynov were of a terrorist disposition."

Chief investigator Agranov took an overnight train from Leningrad to Moscow the night of December 7/8 to meet with Stalin and his inner circle, including Molotov, Lazar Kaganovich, Sergo Ordzhonikidze, Andrei Zhdanov, NKVD chief Yagoda, and future NKVD chief Nikolai Yezhov that afternoon. Zinoviev and his former supporters seem to have been specifically targeted at this time. The following day the NKVD arrested seven former leaders of the Leningrad Communist Party leadership from the period of Zinoviev's primacy — all of whom who had been expelled from the party late in 1927 as oppositionists.

That same day, goaded to provide evidence against "former participants in the counterrevolutionary Trotsky–Zinoviev Opposition," the arrested Vladimir Rumiantsev, a former factional ally of Zinoviev, provided the first direct testimony hinting at direct conspiratorial activity by Zinoviev and Kamenev themselves. The secret police's net was closing in on its ultimate targets.

Arrest, trial, imprisonment, retrial, execution

By the middle of December 1934, following an evolving centrally-created script, personal relationships between former members of the Zinoviev opposition had been used as building blocks detailing an eloborate counterrevolutionary network. Included were parallel organizations identified as the "Moscow Center" and the "Leningrad Center" — the latter of which was said to consist of five underground "groups."

Early in the evening of December 16, NKVD People's Commissar Yagoda, in charge of the Moscow investigation, conducted simultaneous raids on his apartment as well as those of Kamenev and former Leningradskaia pravda editor Georgy Safarov, formerly a close political associate. Even while the raid was going on and old documents being seized, including Zinoviev's 1920s-era correspondence with Trotsky,

The secret investigation now went public, with Pravda and Leningradskaya pravda running an ominous identical lead editorial, "Without Mercy We Must Root Out the Remnants of Our Smashed Enemies!" The remaining dominos fell rapidly. On December 20 the Central Control Commission expelled Zinoviev, Kamenev, Safarov, and 22 others from party membership as "counterrevolutionaries," followed immediately thereafter by arrest.

They were tried in January 1935 and forced to admit "moral complicity" in Kirov's assassination. Zinoviev was sentenced to 10 years in prison and his supporters to various prison terms.

Police photographs of Zinoviev, taken by the NKVD in prison in 1936. In August 1936, after months of rehearsals in secret police prisons, Zinoviev, Kamenev and 14 others, mostly Old Bolsheviks, were put on trial again. This time, the charges included forming a terrorist organization that killed Kirov and tried to kill Stalin and other leaders of the Soviet government. This Trial of the Sixteen (or the trial of the "Trotskyite-Zinovievite Terrorist Center") was the first Moscow Show Trial and set the stage for subsequent show trials where Old Bolsheviks confessed to increasingly elaborate and egregious crimes, including espionage, poisoning and sabotage. Zinoviev and the other defendants were found guilty on 24 August 1936.

Before the trial, Zinoviev and Kamenev had agreed to plead guilty to the false charges on the condition that they not be executed, a condition that Stalin accepted, stating "that goes without saying". A few hours after their conviction, Stalin ordered their execution that night. Shortly after midnight, on the morning of 25 August, Zinoviev and Kamenev were executed by firing squad.

Accounts of Zinoviev's execution vary, with some having him beg and plead for his life, prompting the stoic Kamenev to tell Zinoviev to "quiet down and die with dignity". Zinoviev allegedly struggled against the guards escorting him so fiercely that instead of taking him to the appointed execution room, he was simply dragged into a nearby cell and shot there.

Zinoviev's futile pleading was later re-enacted and mocked by Stalin's personal bodyguard, Karl Pauker. Stalin was described to have "laughed immoderately on seeing an imitation of the old Bolshevik leader Grigori Zinoviev being dragged to his execution, making pleas for mercy with obscenities". Stalin was told Zinoviev's last words were "Hear, O Israel ..." Pauker would himself later perish in the purges.

Legacy

Between 1924 and 1934 Zinoviev's home town of Yelizavetgrad was renamed Zinovyevsk in his honor.

Historian Edward Hallett Carr was more assertive in his negative assessment of Zinoviev, charging him with having been "the initiator of many sinister developments in party history."

Writing more than half a century after Carr, historian Lars Lih put forward a more nuanced view of the "populist Leninist" Zinoviev in a 2011 book:

"Zinoviev was not in the least a systematic thinker who could state a coherent outlook in propositional form. On the other hand, he was an inspirational speaker who very often told stories — small anecdotes from daily life, large narratives about the revolution as a whole — in order to impress his audience. An assessment of the coherence and consistency of his outlook therefore requires a systematic survey of his many speeches during his time in the top leadership of the ruling Bolshevik party."

Despite his abilities as an inspirational orator, Lih characterizes Zinoviev as ultimately a man of "anti-charisma" who promoted simplistic and dubious policy proposals and made tactical political errors that ultimately doomed him in the contest for top leadership in the USSR.

"Zinoviev Letter"

Grigory Zinoviev, Chairman of the Petrograd Soviet, addresses the crowd on the first International Workers' Day after the October Uprising (the Bolshevik Revolution), 1 May 1918. Zinoviev was the alleged author of the "Zinoviev Letter" which caused a sensation in the United Kingdom when published on 25 October 1924, four days before a general election. The letter called on British Communists to prepare for revolution. This document is now generally accepted to have been a fabrication, validating the declaration that Zinoviev made in a letter dated 27 October 1924:

Selected works

Boi za Peterburg: Dve Rechi (The Fight for St. Petersburg: Two Speeches). With Leon Trotsky. St. Petersburg: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel'stvo, 1920. Bolshevizm ili Trotskizm? (with L. Kamenev and I. Stalin) Kursk: Gubkom, 1925. Leninizm: Vvedenie i izuchenie Leninizma [Leninism: Introduction to the Study of Leninism]. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel'stvo, 1925.