Jim McGuinness

Jim McGuinness (born 16 November 1972) is a Gaelic football coach, In addition, McGuinness's Donegal was the only team to defeat Dublin in a championship match during Jim Gavin's time as manager, doing so in the 2014 All-Ireland semi-final, and McGuinness's condensing of the pitch influenced how Dublin subsequently improved over the next five years. McGuinness ended his first spell as Donegal manager shortly after that defeat of Dublin.

McGuinness then became one of very few county team managers to have taken a role at a professional sports team outside Ireland. He began working with the Scottish association football club Celtic as a coach in 2012, progressing to the position of assistant manager its under-20 squad. In 2017, he took up a coaching role with Chinese Super League association football club Beijing Sinobo Guoan, until January 2018. In December 2018, he was named as head coach of USL Championship association football club Charlotte Independence. Over the course of his involvement in association football coaching, McGuinness has worked with figures such as the German Roger Schmidt (formerly Bayer Leverkusen manager) and the Spaniard Félix Sarriugarte (formerly Athletic Bilbao manager).

McGuinness's unexpected return as Donegal senior manager was announced in August 2023. Having previously achieved his UEFA Pro Licence, he was the first person to be appointed as an inter-county Gaelic games manager while holding such a qualification. His brother Charles died suddenly during the night from an unknown heart problem when he was 16. He once wrote a letter to him asking for his jersey.

Playing career McGuinness was called up to the county minors in 1990. He first spotted McGuinness playing in the 1990 Donegal IFC final. McEniff, according to himself and speaking on Up for the Match in 2025, was actually playing that day, as the final was against his own club Réalt na Mara. He called McGuinness onto the Donegal panel. McGuinness told McEniff he was going to America. McEniff said he was not, he was going to stay and play for Donegal.

As a "scraggly-haired teen", McGuinness observed from the bench as McEniff's team defeated Derry in the final of the Ulster Senior Football Championship, before going on to win the All-Ireland Senior Football Championship.

McEniff played McGuinness against Antrim in the 1993 Ulster SFC ("blooded" him, as McEniff said on Up for the Match in 2025). However, by McEniff's account, McGuinness picked up an injury in that game and struggled to recover. McEniff left in 1994. Then, according to McEniff, McGuinness faded away for a while after that, but returned to take a place in later Donegal teams.

McGuinness was also a star of Third-Level Colleges football, winning Sigerson Cups with Tralee in 1998 and 1999 as captain, and again as captain in 2001 with the University of Ulster at Jordanstown (UUJ). At Tralee he studied health and leisure. With Ireland, he played in the 1998 International Rules Series.

He also played for Donegal Boston.

After Donegal lost the final of the 1998 Ulster Senior Football Championship, Jim McGuinness — aged 25 at this time — decided to go to New York for the summer. He started the first game of Brian McEniff's last spell as Donegal manager, a league defeat to Galway in Tuam in February 2003, during which he scored a point. He made a substitute appearance for Paul McGonigle in the 2003 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship semi-final against Armagh. He played with Donegal until 2003. Upon retiring he became a fitness coach and lectured as a sports psychologist in the North West Regional College, Limavady.

Management career in Gaelic football At the age of 18 McGuinness was coaching underage teams. Columba McDyer, at the time the only Donegal man with an All-Ireland SFC medal, approached him one night. He said: "I think you are going to be a coach. I want you to have this whistle", and presented him with a blue and white whistle. As of 2012, McGuinness was still using that whistle.

Naomh Conaill The story goes that one day McGuinness tore his cruciate ligaments, broke a leg and smashed a kneecap in a game against Killybegs, leading to months spent languishing at home in self-pity and lethargy. Naomh Conaill manager Hughie Molloy asked him to coach the senior team—McGuinness accepted and in 2005 Naomh Conaill reached their first county final in 40 years. 6/1 outsiders ahead of the match, Naomh Conaill defeated a heavily fancied St Eunan's after a replay to take their first ever Donegal Senior Football Championship. The style used was reminiscent of what would later become The System.

In 2009, Naomh Conaill met St Eunan's in the County Championship Final again. McGuinness, now aged 36, was joint-manager (with Cathal Corey) of Naomh Conaill. Naomh Conaill lost that one, but won the County Championship Final again the following year.

Donegal McGuinness was turned down several times by the Donegal County Board, on one occasion being thwarted by the lack of a plug socket for the projector needed for his PowerPoint display. "I was the only candidate [on the last occasion] and I struggled to get it", he said the week before Donegal took on Mayo in the 2012 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final.

McGuinness was interviewed for the role of Donegal senior manager in 2007 following Brian McIver's resignation, though McIver was reappointed after reapplying when he decided to carry on. One year later when the role became available again, McGuinness was still the youngest candidate.

Under-21s

The last time he was rejected as senior manager McGuinness was given the under-21 team to manage as a consolation. Brian McEniff, who had remained close to McGuinness since McGuinness was 19 years of age, recommended him after the County Chairman asked him to appoint the next under-21 manager.

McGuinness guided his county to the 2010 All-Ireland Under-21 Football Championship final, in which they were narrowly defeated by Dublin.

Seniors Appointment In July 2010, McGuinness, having led Donegal to the 2010 All-Ireland U-21 Football Championship final, was appointed as manager of the senior team when his colleague John Joe Doherty resigned in the wake of a disastrous season. His first meeting with the downcast and "demoralised" senior panel occurred at Downings Bay Hotel on 6 November 2010. McGuinness drafted Kevin Cassidy into his first McKenna Cup panel, despite Cassidy announcing his intention to retire the previous season's disappointing campaign.

First year Donegal defeated Kildare in the 2011 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship in Jim McGuinness's first season in charge.

McGuinness's first year as manager proved successful, as Donegal gained promotion to Division 1 after defeating Laois by a scoreline of 2–11 to 0–16. Donegal's 2011 All-Ireland SFC campaign began on 15 May 2011, against Antrim. Both sides performed poorly; however, Donegal ultimately triumphed, earning a first win in an Ulster SFC game for four years. On his first start in the Ulster SFC, Ryan Bradley scored two points, and The Sunday Game gave him their man-of-the-match award. However, TV pundit Pat Spillane also claimed Bradley was "the best of a bad bunch" and didn't deserve the award at all, causing McGuinness to react furiously. McGuinness called Spillane's comments "way over the top".

On 17 July 2011, Donegal won their first Ulster title since 1992 when they defeated Derry by a scoreline of 1–11 to 0–8. On 30 July 2011, Donegal faced Kildare in the All-Ireland SFC quarter-final. The sides finished level at full-time, forcing the game into extra-time. Donegal edged out Kildare by a scoreline of 1–12 to 0–14, with late points scored by captain Michael Murphy and two veterans, Christy Toye and Kevin Cassidy. Donegal were then narrowly defeated by Dublin in the semi-final on 28 August 2011; Dublin went on to become All-Ireland champions by defeating Kerry in the final.

On 10 November 2011, McGuinness dropped Kevin Cassidy from the Donegal panel after Cassidy contributed to a book (This Is Our Year). Cassidy appeared not to understand why this was so. He never played for Donegal again. In what went down as a "surreal moment for the viewer", Mícheál Ó Domhnaill famously interviewed McGuinness following a live 2012 league game on TG4 while Cassidy, in the role of television analyst, stood beside him with his head bowed.

Second year

In his second season in charge of the Donegal senior football team, McGuinness led his team from the preliminary round of the Ulster SFC all the way to the Sam Maguire Cup, two years ahead of schedule, half-way through his intended Olympiad. McGuinness then masterminded a comprehensive defeat of Kerry in the All-Ireland SFC quarter-final between the teams. This result was described by the national media as "the most seismic result in [Kerry] since the 1987 Munster final replay defeat to Cork". Pat Spillane, prominent critic of the team, was nowhere to be seen after this defeat of his own team, though he bumped into Jim McGuinness on the steps of a hotel the following week as McGuinness was being photographed receiving an award.

McGuinness then led his team to the 2012 All-Ireland SFC final, with a comprehensive semi-final defeat of title-favourites Cork at Croke Park. Ahead of the match, Cork were favourites to win the title itself (even though this was only the semi-final). Tyrone's Mickey Harte, attempting to analyse the game for the BBC, expressed his shock: "To be honest, I could not see that coming. Donegal annihilated Cork, there is no other word for it". Martin McHugh, a member of the successful 1992 side, said it was the best ever performance by any Donegal team, including his own.

McGuinness's Donegal team defeated Mayo in the 2012 All-Ireland SFC final. McGuinness duetted with Daniel O'Donnell on "Destination Donegal" at the homecoming. He was later awarded Donegal Person of the Year.

Third year Donegal's defence of their All-Ireland SFC title began against Tyrone on 26 May 2013. The match was billed in advance as the toughest contest Donegal would face in Ulster, with the winner thought likely to become Ulster champions. Donegal brushed aside Tyrone with relative ease. McGuinness said afterwards: "In the last two years the exact same thing was said. The only difference this year was that we were relegated [from the league]. There was a lot of talk about putting all the eggs into one basket, but it was the same last year and the same the year before. That's what we do — it's championship football. It will be no different next year. It was a media spin that got the whole debate going. Next year we will put all our eggs in that basket again".

Donegal lost their Ulster SFC title to Monaghan in the Ulster SFC final on a scoreline of 0–13 points to 0–7 in favour of the Farney men. Plagued by injuries, they limped past Laois in the qualifiers to face Mayo in the 2013 All-Ireland SFC quarter-final, a rematch of the previous year's All-Ireland SFC final. Mayo were sixteen-point winners on a scoreline of 4–17 to 1–10. In a post-match interview, McGuinness cited the second half of Mayo as one of the toughest watches of his managerial career. In September 2013, McGuinness confirmed he would be staying on for the 2014 season, but that Rory Gallagher, Maxi Curran and Francie Friel had stepped down from his backroom team. On 25 September 2013, Damian Diver, John Duffy and Paul McGonigle were named as the new members of McGuinness's backroom team.

Fourth year

In his fourth season in charge of the Donegal senior football team, McGuinness led his team to the 2014 Ulster SFC title, then past Armagh in the 2014 All-Ireland SFC quarter-final, past Dublin in the All-Ireland SFC semi-final and onwards to Kerry in the 2014 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final, succeeding in his original aim, set back in 2010. Dublin had been expected to "massacre" Donegal; bookmakers were stunned by the outcome. Martin McHugh said afterwards that McGuinness was "the best manager Donegal have ever had, and one of the best in any county in the modern era", while Ireland manager Paul Earley hailed the victory as McGuinness's greatest coaching achievement. Donegal lost to Kerry in the final, by the scoreline 2:08 to 0:11. On 4 October 2014, McGuinness terminated his first tenure as Donegal manager. He had managed Donegal through 54 league and championship matches. He won 83.33 per cent of his SFC matches during his first spell as Donegal manager (20 wins from 24 games); this included defeats, over a four-year period, of Armagh, Cavan, Cork, Derry, Dublin, Down, Kildare, Kerry, Mayo, Monaghan and Tyrone.

Soon afterwards, McGuinness gave his first interview since departing, on RTÉ television programme The Saturday Night Show.

Galway footballers In October 2020, McGuinness was seen taking charge of a training session for the Galway football team. He later stated it was a once off session that happened as a result of being asked by Galway manager Pádraic Joyce.

Later work with Naomh Conaill He assisted his club Naomh Conaill with their defensive system during the 2022 Donegal Senior Football Championship, working with the team between the semi-final and final.

Donegal: The Second Coming quote="He is a leader of men who barks orders on the sideline with no problem telling his players what he thinks of their efforts on the pitch at different stages, if needed, but greets them like a proud father once the final whistle is blown. They embrace him like a lifelong friend that they would do anything for." — Michael Verney—Irish Independent in 2025 On 20 August, Donegal GAA brought forward its monthly county board meeting to the following evening, where the only thing on the agenda was about appointing the new manager. Finally, on the evening of Monday the 21st of August, the return of McGuinness was confirmed in sensational fashion at that meeting, year one of three (with an option of a fourth) beginning pronto. It was big news the length and breadth of the sport throughout the island, with James Horan's return to the Mayo fold that same evening having to settle for second place as Horan slipped in quietly amid all the fuss over McGuinness.

The appointment made McGuinness the first holder of a UEFA Pro Licence to manage an inter-county team.

Fifth year For the 2024 season, McGuinness led Donegal to the National Football League Division 2 title (and, with that, promotion to Division 1), the Ulster SFC title and the All-Ireland SFC semi-final, an exact replica of his first year (even with the exact same two-point defeat at the All-Ireland SFC semi-final stage). He did this without his All-Ireland SFC-winning captain Michael Murphy, who had decided to retire from inter-county football after the 2022 season.

Sixth year In the 2025 season, Michael Murphy returned from his self-imposed exile and McGuinness led Donegal to another All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final but were beaten by 10 points by Kerry.

Media career In 2014, Sky Sports secured a three-year deal to broadcast live matches from the All-Ireland Senior Football and Hurling Championships. McGuinness spent three years as a pundit for Sky before departing in 2017. He returned as an analyst for Sky in 2020.

Book McGuinness's autobiography Until Victory Always: A Memoir was released in October 2015, and he gave a televised interview to The Late Late Show.

Depictions

McGuinness's image has been represented on a mural outside Glenties, and a statue bearing the epigraph "Jim the Redeemer" was erected at Laghy close to Lough Derg. Since his Second Coming, McGuinness has even been depicted as "God himself", emerging from clouds, in swirling robes, with arms outstretched, the sun to his left and a cross to his right. As The Irish Times stated in 2025: "If McEniff is the godfather, then McGuinness is the messiah".

Soccer coaching career After McGuinness led Donegal to the All-Ireland SFC title, the father of Paul McGinley (an acquaintance of McGuinness) asked him to talk to the Irish golfer about coaching so that he could captain Team Europe in the Ryder Cup. In May 2015, McGuinness said he would begin his UEFA B Licence coaching badge. He had received it by January 2017. He began his UEFA A Licence in July 2017. He later received it. McGuinness successfully applied to the Football Association of Ireland (FAI) to study for a UEFA Pro Licence in 2019, his classmates including Damien Duff and Robbie Keane. As of 2023, and upon his appointment again as Donegal senior manager, McGuinness had completed his UEFA Pro Licence.

Celtic The golfer Paul McGinley mentioned McGuinness to Dermot Desmond after speaking with the Donegal manager. Desmond invited McGuinness to several UEFA Champions League games played by the Scottish association football club Celtic, in Glasgow. It was expected that he would remain as the Donegal manager, spending three days each week in Scotland focusing on the soccer club's academy structure at their Lennoxtown training centre. His role at Celtic did not affect his attendance at Donegal training sessions; he attended every one.

After a stint as performance consultant, he later took over as youth coach. He resigned for "personal, family reasons" just over six months later in January 2018.

Charlotte Independence In December 2018, McGuinness was named as the new head coach of Charlotte Independence in the USL Championship, where he signed a three-year contract. He was unveiled at a press conference in Montrose, South Dublin. McGuinness also secured the loan signings of defender Andrew Gutman and Scotland national team midfielder Mark Hill, in February and March 2019 respectively. However, on 12 June 2019, McGuinness was sacked as head coach after just one win in 14 games in the 2019 USL Championship season. Independence President and Managing Partner Jim McPhilliamy thanked McGuinness for improving the club "in many ways, including bringing talent to our roster and instituting new training methodologies", and blamed the club's hierarchy, saying they wanted to keep some of his training methods in the future.

Approach from Dundalk In May 2020, Jim Magilton, the sporting director of League of Ireland Premier Division club Dundalk, said he had spoken to McGuinness about the club's managerial vacancy. Dundalk offered McGuinness a temporary position as a coach, but McGuinness was not interested.

Personal life McGuinness's wife Yvonne is a sister of Colm McFadden. They have six children: Toni-Marie, Mark Anthony, Jim Jnr, Bonnie, Aoibhe, and a boy, born in 2016.

The family moved to the United States when McGuinness took up the job as manager of Charlotte Independence in 2018, and were still living there as of 2020.