Sarah Schupansky

Club career Gotham FC

Gotham FC announced on December 23, 2024, that they had signed Schupansky to her first professional contract on a two-year deal with the team option to extend another year. She made her professional debut in the season opener against the Seattle Reign, starting and being named player of the match after the 1–1 draw on March 15, 2025. On April 19, she registered her first professional assist to Esther in a 4–0 win over Angel City FC. The following week, she scored her first professional goal and assisted Esther again as Gotham won 3–0 against the Washington Spirit. On May 24, she started in the CONCACAF W Champions Cup final against Tigres, helping Gotham win 1–0 to become the inaugural winners of the competition.

On September 15, 2025, Schupansky signed a contract extension with Gotham through 2027. She finished her rookie season with 1 goal and 5 assists in 23 regular-season appearances, ranking tied for second in the league in assists. She made her playoff debut in the quarterfinals, helping eighth-seeded Gotham win 2–1 against NWSL Shield winners Kansas City Current. In the NWSL Championship against the Washington Spirit, she played a long ball to Bruninha to set up Rose Lavelle's goal in the 1–0 victory. During a year and a half with Gotham, she made 49 appearances and scored 1 goal in all competitions, collecting three trophies.

Boston Legacy

On August 21, 2026, Schupansky was traded to the Boston Legacy for in allocation funds and in intraleague transfer funds.

International career Schupansky was called into training camp with the United States under-23 team, practicing concurrently with the senior national team, in March 2025.

Honors and awards

Gotham FC NWSL Championship: 2025 CONCACAF W Champions Cup: 2024–25

Individual First-team All-ACC: 2023 Second-team All-ACC: 2024 NCAA Division I assists leader: 2024