Jeffrey Maier

The Jeffrey Maier incident occurred during Game 1 of the 1996 American League Championship Series between the New York Yankees and the Baltimore Orioles. Twelve-year-old Jeffrey Maier deflected a batted ball, hit by Derek Jeter, into the Yankee Stadium stands for what umpires ruled to be a home run, rather than fan interference. His interference altered the course of Game 1. The resulting home run allowed the Yankees to tie the score. They were victorious in the game and won the series four games to one. "Maier became an immediate celebrity in New York, a pariah in Baltimore and an everlasting character in baseball lore."

Incident

On October 9, 1996, the Yankees trailed the Orioles 4–3 in the bottom of the eighth inning when shortstop Derek Jeter hit a deep fly ball to right field. Right fielder Tony Tarasco moved near the fence and appeared "to draw a bead on the ball" when the then-12-year-old Maier clearly reached over the fence separating the stands and the field of play nine feet below and attempted to catch the ball with his glove. Maier failed to make the catch but he knocked the ball over the fence in his attempt. While baseball fans are permitted to catch (and keep) balls hit into the stands, the Major League Baseball rulebook states that spectator interference is to be called if "a spectator reaches out of the stands, or goes on the playing field, and touches a live ball".

Right field umpire Rich Garcia immediately ruled the play a home run, tying the game at 4–4, despite the protest of Tarasco and Orioles manager Davey Johnson (the latter was ejected in the ensuing argument). After viewing the replay, Garcia admitted he made a mistake and that there was spectator interference, but maintained Maier reached out, not down, and did not interfere with Tarasco's ability to catch the ball and that Tarasco would not have caught it. Tarasco adamantly disagreed, maintaining he would have caught the ball without Maier's interference. Had Garcia called spectator interference, he would have then used his own judgment to determine what the most likely outcome of the play would beeither an out or awarding Jeter a given number of bases.

Garcia accepted Orioles fans later booing him, but was disturbed when Yankees fans cheered him, as he did not want to appear biased. Two days after the incident Garcia said no one felt worse about it than he did, but that one play after 22 years of hard work as an umpire should not make him hang his head, adding, "I love Baltimore, I love the team and I love this stadium [ Camden Yards]...." The New York Times described him as having become "New York royalty". The New York Daily News allowed him to sit behind the Yankee dugout during the World Series. The boy appeared on national talk shows. On the other end, a 2012 article in the Baltimore Sun began, "The most despised child in the history of Baltimore sports is all grown up." Then Yankees' manager Joe Torre said after the incident, "I think it's glorifying the wrong thing." Maier himself has come to terms more over the years with the impact of the incident as he has grown older, married, and become a father. He has stated, "'It's a huge part of baseball history, either positive or negative depending on your allegiance, but it's part of history nonetheless.'"